Showing posts with label The Economist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Economist. Show all posts

2011/02/20

It ain't broke

Plans to discourage foreign students threaten a successful British business

Student visas

Thanks for the memories
 
TWO countries, keen rivals in the increasingly competitive market for international students, announced reviews of their visa systems in December. Australia, which has seen applications from foreign students fall since it began tightening the rules to combat immigration fraud in 2008, is thinking of relaxing them again to boost numbers. Britain, which has also been cracking down on abuse, wants to tighten its system further. At a time when university funding is being squeezed and exports are expected to power the shaky economic recovery, this approach has its critics.

Britain has recently experienced the largest wave of immigration in its history. This contributed to a long stretch of economic growth, but has also provoked unease about jobs, wages, public services and terrorism. Before last year’s general election the Conservatives made a pledge to cut annual net immigration, currently around 200,000, to the “tens of thousands” by the end of this parliament; now in government (with the Liberal Democrats), they are trying to meet it. The trouble is that many immigrants are either Britons returning from abroad or other European citizens who can’t be kept out.

Thus in November the coalition government announced a permanent and controversial cut in the number of non-Europeans coming in to work (a fifth of the total in 2009); this week it revealed that those earning more than £150,000 ($240,000) would be exempted from the new limit. Students are a far bigger target, accounting for well over half of non-European migrants, and their numbers have been rising (see chart). It isn’t surprising that they are in the government’s sights too.
Yet students contribute some £10 billion a year to Britain’s economy, guesses Dominic Scott, chief executive of the UK Council for International Student Affairs, a pressure group. Higher education alone is the country’s seventh-biggest export, reckons Steve Smith, of Universities UK, another lobby. Foreign university students subsidise domestic ones, who pay lower fees, and keep labs open: they do the lion’s share of postgraduate scientific research. And many schools are thriving and creating jobs thanks to foreign students. 

All the same, there are worries that student visas are used as an easy way into Britain’s labour market. Some immigrants sign up at bogus colleges that provide little or no education; some students never leave. An attempt by the UK Borders Agency (UKBA) to quantify visa fraud found much flouting of the rules at private further-education colleges in particular (and, to a lesser extent, at language schools). Damian Green, the immigration minister, thunders against people who ostensibly study in London while working in Wales.

But the government, desperate to redeem a misguided promise, seems to be reaching for a hatchet instead of a scalpel. Though firm proposals are not expected until March, the broad outlines of the likely changes are clear. Only “highly trusted” schools and colleges will be allowed to offer foreigners courses below university level. Applicants might have to show a better grasp of English than in the past. Those who want to go on from one course to another might have to go home to apply for another visa. And the prized right to stay and work for two years after completing a degree is likely to be reduced or removed. 

Nervous colleges protest that the previous government had already made the system tougher—by, for instance, raising the English-language requirement for visa applicants. The register of outfits entitled to recruit foreign students had been whittled down from more than 12,000 to around 2,200 UKBA-approved establishments by March 2009; since then 60 more have been struck off and 68 are currently suspended. Over a quarter of institutions have agreed to stricter reporting standards in order to become “highly trusted sponsors”.

Immigration rules aren’t the only factor affecting students’ choice of country: Australia might have suffered as much from its strong currency and some well-publicised xenophobic incidents as from a harsher visa regime. Britain has the English language and an enviable reputation for quality. But visa rules matter: many schools reported a decline in Japanese business after the last tightening of the language requirement. The British Council, a cultural body, says there is concern in China, in particular, over the coming shake-up.



Internship The Britain section will soon be choosing an intern to work for several months this summer. Applicants should send a letter and an article of about 600 words that they think would be suitable for publication. A small stipend will be paid. Applications must reach britainintern@economist.com by March 19th.

2010/11/22

Still choppy

The inflation overshoot

Still choppy

The economic conditions are not ideal to launch a British version of QE2

THE routine has become familiar. Inflation surprises on the upside. It is high enough to warrant another note from Mervyn King, the governor of the Bank of England, to George Osborne, the chancellor of the exchequer, to explain what is going on. That note says, in essence, that the overshoot was caused by temporary factors and that inflation will eventually subside because of spare capacity opened up in the recession. But will it?


This week’s letter from Mr King was the fourth he has had to write this year as inflation has persistently strayed more than a percentage point above the 2% target. It was prompted by official figures showing that consumer prices rose by a higher-than-expected 3.2% in the year to October (see chart), up from 3.1% in September. Indeed, in nine letters since April 2007, Mr King has been obliged to explain why inflation has been above 3%. 

That inflation has remained stubbornly high in the wake of the most severe recession since the second world war is odd. In this respect, Britain is unusual among advanced economies, as other figures also published this week highlighted. Inflation in the euro area in the year to October ran at 1.9%; in America it was 1.2%.

The main reason why Britain has been the exception is the steep fall in the pound, whose trade-weighted value slumped by some 25% between mid-2007 and early 2009. Even though the effects on inflation through higher import prices should be waning now, there have been other adverse temporary influences, such as past rises in oil prices and the return of the main rate of VAT, a consumption tax, to 17.5% at the start of 2010, after 13 months in which it was set at 15% as part of the previous government’s fiscal stimulus. 

The difficulty for the bank’s monetary-policy committee (MPC) is that there will be yet more temporary factors pushing inflation up over the next year. In January VAT will rise again, to 20%, an increase that is expected to be passed through in full to prices, whereas only half of its preceding fall and rise are reckoned to have been passed on. Moreover, world food prices have been climbing steeply. 

In January Mr King said that “in both of the past two years inflation picked up as a result of temporary price-level factors and then fell back, as the MPC had predicted.” But the bank’s own central forecast, published on November 10th, shows that inflation will reach 3.6% in the first quarter of next year and will not fall below 3% until early 2012. Just what “temporary” means in the bank’s lexicon is unclear.

The risk in this, as the governor acknowledged in his latest letter to Mr Osborne, is that people start to expect higher inflation. The bank argues that expectations remain consistent with hitting the inflation target in the medium term. However, two out of three household surveys show that expectations of inflation one year ahead have been moving up. 

The big picture, as Mr King sees it, is that the slack in the economy following the steep recession will eventually pull down inflation. This remains plausible. Average earnings are growing at only 2% according to official figures out this week; the unemployment rate is a still-high 7.7%. But financial crises tend to inflict a lot of damage on capacity. That could mean that the margin of spare resources is not that large, which would chime with surveys of businesses. 

Mr King is still being given the benefit of the doubt, but he must be chary of his stock of credibility. The inflation overshoots make it more difficult for the bank to follow the United States, where the Federal Reserve has launched another bout of quantitative easing nicknamed QE2. That lifeboat won’t be launched in Britain in the near future, unless there is very clear evidence that the recovery is foundering.

Gang that can't shoot straight

European leaders are blamed for exacerbating the euro crisis, but for the wrong reasons


IN MAY, when they rescued Greece from the bond markets at the 11th hour, the members of the euro zone vowed never to get into such a mess again. To keep the speculators at bay, they armed themselves with the biggest gun they could muster: a trillion-dollar loan fund. Many hoped the weapon would prove such a deterrent that, like the “bazooka” of Hank Paulson, America’s treasury secretary under George Bush, it would never have to be used. Yet, just as with Mr Paulson’s guarantee, the euro zone’s weapon barely deterred the barbarians. 

Now Ireland is under assault and the euro zone has loaded the first bullet into the chamber. On November 16th euro-zone finance ministers said there would be a “short and focused consultation”, involving the European Commission, the European Central Bank and the IMF, to assess the best way of helping Ireland to salvage its collapsed banks (see article). There has been a curious role reversal between the Greek crisis in May and the Irish one now. In the spring everything was made worse by the hesitation of the main donor, Germany, over helping spendthrift Greeks. This time it is the would-be recipient, Ireland, that is prevaricating dangerously. Yet, like it or not, the rescue party is being saddled up. Will it succeed?
It would certainly help if the riders showed better order and learnt to shoot straight. The German chancellor, Angela Merkel, is at the forefront, but she is also the subject of much mutinous talk since leading her colleagues into the badlands at last month’s EU summit. She persuaded them to reopen last year’s Lisbon treaty to create a bail-out system that would allow the restructuring of a country’s debts. No longer, she declared, would good European taxpayers have to bear the risk of protecting their financial system alone; she would exact a price from speculators too. Jean-Claude Trichet, the ECB president, warned the leaders that they risked stirring up restive markets, but was ignored.
Within days, the euro countries cantered into a new ambush. Yields on the bonds of weak countries broke new euro-zone records. A fortnight later, at the Seoul G20 summit, Mrs Merkel was still in combative mood. “Let me put it simply: in this regard there may be a contradiction between the interests of the financial world and the interests of the political world.” But a day later the EU sent out a peace party. The finance ministers of the five biggest countries explained that they had been misunderstood. The debts of euro-zone members were protected by their bail-out fund until 2013; any notion of imposing “haircuts” on bondholders would apply only to new debt issued thereafter.

For economists such as Jean Pisani-Ferry, director of Bruegel, a think-tank in Brussels, Mrs Merkel’s action was a good idea that went wrong. Investors should indeed bear some of the pain, but she would have done better to venture into this territory next year, once markets had calmed down, and with a proper map. Brian Cowen, Ireland’s prime minister, grumbled about the turmoil being an “unforeseen consequence” of the German move. His Greek colleague, George Papandreou, was less charitable. Germany, he said, risked creating “a self-fulfilling prophecy”. It was placing greater burdens on countries already in trouble. “This could break backs. This could force economies towards bankruptcy.” Wolfgang Schäuble, the German finance minister, made clear he thought the Greeks were being ungrateful for the help they received earlier this year. 

Other politicians have exacerbated matters, too. Portuguese ministers spoke openly about needing a rescue or even having to leave the euro. Hours before the finance ministers’ meeting, Herman Van Rompuy, president of the European Council, carelessly talked of Europe being “in a survival crisis”. It was left to Olli Rehn, the laconic Finnish economic commissioner, to call for “cool heads”. Plainly, the rescue of Ireland is not made any easier by all the political bickering. But in a union of 27 countries, decisions inevitably take longer and messages get more confused than markets would like. European politicians who delayed the Greek rescue and now seem to be making a dog’s dinner of the Irish one deserve blame for responding slowly and fitfully to the signals from financial markets—a charge that has much resonance when it comes to the Germans. Yet it would be wrongheaded to leap from this to blaming Germany for the euro’s crisis.

It was the Greeks, not the Germans, who lied about their deficit numbers (this week, the true Greek deficit for 2009 was pushed up again by the European statisticians, to 15.4% of GDP). It was Dublin (and Madrid), not Berlin, that presided cheerfully over a hugely inflated house-price bubble. It was Irish politicians, not German ones, who happily took plenty of campaign-finance contributions from their property-developer chums. Mrs Merkel has much to answer for when it comes to running a large current-account surplus and imparting a deflationary bias to the euro zone. But she is not to blame for the feckless failure of weaker euro-zone countries to push through reforms that might have made up for their loss of competitiveness.

The benefit of self-harm

If there is any silver lining at all to emerge from the turmoil of recent weeks, it is that the value of the euro has fallen, or at least that it has stopped rising. A euro crisis is certainly an expensive way to achieve this goal, but at least exporters will be grateful. According to the latest figures, the euro zone as a whole posted a larger-than-expected trade surplus in September. Many feared that the euro might get caught in the crossfire of the currency war between America and China. They were wrong. Ranged against the shotgun of America’s quantitative easing, and the shield of China’s capital controls, Europe does at least have leaders who are well drilled in shooting themselves in the foot.


Old wine in new bottles

 

Nicolas Sarkozy’s much-touted reshuffle proves to be a small one that keeps the prime minister in place


FOR six months, President Nicolas Sarkozy had been preparing the French for a new government. His advisers had floated the names of various possible successors to François Fillon, the prime minister, and these aspirants were jockeying frenziedly. Over the weekend, the president spun out the suspense, securing the resignation of the old government 24 hours before unveiling a new one. Yet in the end, a man who prides himself for his daring and decisiveness did nothing more than reappoint Mr Fillon, along with a clutch of others, including Christine Lagarde, the finance minister, and Brice Hortefeux, the interior minister.

If Mr Sarkozy was seeking to rebrand his government, he missed the mark. The reappointment of Mr Fillon, who is now expected to stay until the 2012 presidential election, is an almost unprecedented individual triumph. Under the Fifth Republic, French prime ministers have been treated as dispensable, to be sacked whenever things go badly. Just weeks ago, Mr Sarkozy argued in private that his old team was worn out and needed renewing. Mr Fillon, according to a friend, had even rented a new apartment in Paris. But Mr Sarkozy’s mistake was not to have a credible alternative. Given the prime minister’s greater popularity among voters and deputies, Mr Sarkozy risked trouble from having him outside the tent. By dithering, he has emerged weaker and Mr Fillon stronger.

Much of the rest of the new team is anything but. Out has gone the big-tent approach that embraced the left as well as the centre and lent Mr Sarkozy’s first government its originality. All but one of the six figures from the left have disappeared, including Bernard Kouchner, who was sacked as foreign minister. Out too went leading centrists, including Jean-Louis Borloo, the environment minister, and several liberals. Denied the prime minister’s job that he thought was within his grasp, Mr Borloo declined a lesser post and walked off in a huff. 

The new government draws heavily on the old guard from the Gaullist RPR party founded by Jacques Chirac, which Mr Sarkozy broadened to the centre under the UMP umbrella for the 2007 presidential election. With the return of Alain Juppé, Mr Chirac’s prime minister in the mid-1990s, who takes over at defence, and the transfer of Michèle Alliot-Marie from justice to the foreign ministry, the new government has a chiraquien feel. François Baroin, another Chirac protégé, keeps his job as budget minister. Indeed, for a president who promised a rupture with the Chirac era, his new team would not look out of place under the old Gaullist. French satirists had a field day, as did the opposition. “So much fuss for so little!”, mocked Martine Aubry, the Socialist leader.

Mr Sarkozy, who appeared live on prime-time television this week, seems to want to accomplish three things with his narrower Gaullist line-up. One is to create a more cohesive team. Although the broad-based approach was arresting, it was blamed for confusing supporters on the right, as well as for personality clashes. One by one, left-wingers such as Jean-Pierre Jouyet, a former Europe minister, have quit. Most of the ethnic-minority faces have been dumped. Rachida Dati went last year; Rama Yade and Fadela Amara this time. Eric Woerth, a minister caught up in a party-financing judicial investigation linked to Liliane Bettencourt, the billionaire heiress to the L’Oréal cosmetics empire, has been fired. By tightening the team around his base, Mr Sarkozy may hope to thwart damaging scandals and rows and present a more unified front. 

The second aim, which remains to be tested, is to return to a more traditional form of governing. Mr Sarkozy conceded that there should be a more balanced division of labour with his prime minister. His advisers are to appear less in public, leaving ministers to get on with their jobs. The president himself, studiously calm during his TV appearance, intends to stand back a bit. Jetting about during France’s presidency of the G20 will occupy a big chunk of his time. Laurent Joffrin, editor of Libération, a left-wing newspaper, called this a shift from baroque to classical: “sarkozysme without the excess”.

Third, and despite the chiraquien flavour of the new government, Mr Sarkozy wants to pursue structural reforms. Until recently, he was himself arguing for a pause. This week, by contrast, he said he wanted “to make all five years effective for France”. He announced a rethink of the tax system by next summer, based partly on Germany’s fiscal structure, and a new form of social security to finance care of the elderly. The idea is to make both budget-neutral. Mr Fillon is a good choice to make sure of this. He was a lone voice in 2007 when he declared that “France is bankrupt”. This week, he said that his “absolute priority” was still to trim the deficit. 

Although the reappointment of Mr Fillon is popular, in the short run the reshuffle is unlikely to lift Mr Sarkozy’s approval ratings from their record lows. Voters do not seem to give him much credit for holding out through weeks of strikes and protests to lift the minimum retirement age from 60 to 62, although that may change in time. Some deputies still wonder, privately, if he is the best man to lead the French right into the 2012 election. One poll last week suggested that, in a presidential run-off, Mr Sarkozy would be beaten, albeit narrowly, by Ms Aubry—but that, if she faced Mr Fillon instead, he would be victorious.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...